Postseason Honors
NCAA All-Americans
1999: Mike Simpson, 3B (1st)
2000: Jonathan Krysa, P (1st)
2010: Ryan Porter, 1B (3rd)
2012: Mark Sappington, P (3rd)
NAIA All-Americans
1995: Jason Lee
NAIA Hall of Fame
1964: Jimmy Gleeson
All-Great Lakes Valley Conference
2006: Mike Walczuk, DH (2nd); Andrew Silver, SP (2nd); Logan McElwain, RP (2nd); Jared Pitts, 2B (HM)
2007: Patrick Larm, SP (2nd); Frank Allen, RP (2nd)
2008: Zach Troilo, OF (3rd)
2009: Mike Walczuk, DH (1st); Jordan Myers, 2B (2nd); Tyler Knust, 3B (2nd); Zach Troilo, OF (3rd); Jeremy Pope, SP (3rd); Ryan Porter, 1B (3rd)
2010: Ryan Porter, 1B (1st); Mark Himmelberg, SP (3rd)
2011: Ryan Porter, 1B (1st); Brandon Tangney, OF (2nd); Patrick Chandler, OF (3rd)
2012: Ryan Porter, 1B (1st, West); Scott Bradbury, 3B (1st, West); T.J. Dailey, C (1st, West); Patrick Chandler, OF (1st, West); Mark Sappington, SP (1st, West); Tyler Gans, 2B (2nd, West); Mark Himmelberg, SP (2nd, West); Josh Tols, SP (2nd, West)
2013: Tyler Gans, 2B (1st, West); Jordan Eckley, 3B (1st, West); Patrick Chandler, OF (2nd, West); Alex Seier, SP (2nd, West)
2014: Calin McCourt, OF (2nd, West); Josh Tols, P (2nd, West)
2015: Brett Marr, SS (1st, West)
2016: Seth Soto, 3B (1st, West); David Stober, OF (1st, West); Henry Weiler, UT (2nd, West); Joey Mancuso, C (1st, West); Brandon Mikulka, DH (2nd, West)
2017: Brett Marr, SS (1st, West); Michael Lydon-Lorson, F (1st, West); Henry Weiler, UT (2nd, West); Andrew Ellwanger, P (2nd, West)
2018: Henry Weiler, UT (1st, West); Corbin Hare, OF (2nd, West)
2019: Nathan Mark, DH (1st); Jack Eisenbarger, P (2nd); Garrett McNally, 3B (2nd)
2021: Jack Eisenbarger, SP (1st); Tyler Stamer, OF (1st)
2022: Michael Laudando, UT (1st), SP (2nd)
2023: Adonis Forte, OF (1st)
2024: Adonis Forte, OF (1st); Michael Laudando, UT (1st); Jake Canent, RP (1st); Michael Laudando, SP (2nd)
2025: Adonis Forte, OF (1st); Michael Laudando, UT (1st); Jake Canent, P (2d); Matthew Brimacombe, OF (HM)
GLVC Freshman of the Year
2009: Ryan Porter
2010: Brandon Tangney
2022: Michael Laudando
Rawlings D2 Gold Glove
2016: Brett Marr, SS
All-Heartland Conference
2004: Josh Hydeman, IF; Colby Parks, P
2005: Ray Chang, IF; Jared Pitts, IF; Shane Lankford, OF; Andrew Silver, P
Heartland Player of the Year
2005: Ray Chang
Heartland Coach of the Year
2004: Gary Burns
