Postseason Honors
NCAA All-Americans (National Soccer Coaches)
First Team
2005 – Cody Anderson, F (3rd)
2007 – Tom Heinemann, F (2nd)
2008 – Chad Becker, GK (1st)
2008 – Tom Heinemann, F (1st)
2008 – Kyle Samuelson, M (3rd)
2011 – Mark Magee, F (1st)
2011 – Kyle Miller, D (1st)
2011 – Paolo Scoppola, M (2nd)
2011 – Ryan Bass, GK (2nd)
2011 – Lucas De Rossi, M (3rd)
2012 – Mark Magee, F (2nd)
2012 – Ryan Bass, GK (2nd)
2013 – Mark Magee, F (3rd)
2015 – Paul Dean, D (1st)
2016 – Kaleb Jackson, F (3rd)
2017 – Kaleb Jackson, F (1st)
2017 – Adam Michel, M (2nd)
NCAA All-Tournament Team
2013 – Oussie Gueye, D
2015 – Nick Caruso, D
2016 – Mitch Moncada, F
2017 – Adam Michel, M; Luca Mastrantonio, D
NCAA Tournament Elite 90 Award
2016 – Gianluca Bottoni, M
NAIA All-Americans
1973 – Ron Pimmel, F (HM)
1973 – Bill Schaefer, D (HM)
1975 – John Malinee, M (HM)
1975 – Denny Lee, F (1st)
1977 – John Malinee, M (1st)
1977 – Keith Gehling, D (1st)
1978 – Craig Stahl, F (1st)
1978 – Mark Scott, M (1st)
1978 – Rick Streb, D (2nd)
1979 – Chris Sielfleisch, D (2nd)
1979 – Craig Stahl, F (2nd)
1979 – Mike Powers, M (2nd)
1980 – Ken Schubert, D (1st)
1980 – Craig Stahl, F (1st)
1980 – John Dussold, M (HM)
1984 – Skip Reh, F (2nd)
1984 – Joe Stephens, D (2nd)
1985 – John Makowski, D (3rd)
1985 – Jim Ross, F (3rd)
1985 – Declan Mooney, M (3rd)
1986 – John Makowski, D (2nd)
1986 – Mark Visconti, F (3rd)
1986 – Kurt Schoen, M (3rd)
1988 – Kevin Koetters, M (2nd)
1989 – Kevin Koetters, D (2nd)
1989 – Jon Parry, F (2nd)
1990 – Jon Parry, F (1st)
1990 – Darrell Williams, D (1st)
1990 – David Reichart, M (2nd)
1990 – Jeff Johnson, GK (3rd)
1991 – Jon Parry, F (1st)
1991 – Greg Herdlick, D (2nd)
1991 – Tom Knox, M (3rd)
1993 – Todd Schieffer, D (1st)
1993 – Jeff Klusman, M (1st)
1993 – Jim McMullen, F (2nd)
1994 – Diego Gutierrez, M (2nd)
1994 – Jeff Klusman, M (1st)
1994 – Mike House, D (3rd)
1995 – Diego Gutierrez, M (1st)
1995 – Jeff Klusman, M (2nd)
1996 – Thomas Andreasen, F (1st)
1996 – Blair Quinn, GK (1st)
1996 – Kevin Schoen, F (2nd)
1997 – Thomas Andreasen, F (1st)
1996 – Kevin Schoen, F (2nd)
1997 – Doug Grojean, D (1st)
1998 – Thomas Andreasen, F (2nd)
NAIA All-Tournament Team
1967 – Luis Castro, F; Geoff Melchior, M; Mike Morrell, D; Mike Tucker, D
1973 – Rich Suit, M
1975 – Denny Lee, F; John Malinee, M
1976 – Keith Gehling, D
1978 – Rick Streb, D
1979 – Craig Stahl, F (MVP); Jim Halaz, GK
1986 – John Makowski, D; John Hungerford, D
1989 – Kevin Koetters, D; Tom Knox, M
1990 – Jon Parry, F; Darrell Williams, D
1994 – Diego Gutierrez, M
1997 – Thomas Andreasen, F
NCAA Division II Academic All-Americans
First Team
2016 – Gianluca Bottoni, M
2023 – Jacopo Belardo, M
2024 – Jacopo Belardo, M
Third Team
2010 – Patrick White, D
National Soccer Coaches Scholar All-Americans
2011 – Ryan Bass, GK
2015 – Paul Dean, D
2016 – Gianluca Bottoni, M
2017 – Evan Craig, D
2017 – Kaleb Jackson, F
2017 – Connor Mullen, M
NAIA Scholar-Athlete All-Americans
1985 – Daniel Dufour
1986 – Daniel Dufour
1988 – Sean Phelan
1989 – Sean Phelan
1992 – Todd Schieffer
1993 – Todd Schieffer
1994 – Jeff Klusman, Kelly Klusman
1997 – Chad Feurstein
All-Great Lakes Valley Conference
2005: Haggai Leboo, F (1st team); Cody Anderson, F (1st team); Tom Heinemann, F (2nd team); Darren Rahe, M (HM); Rhodri Payne, D (HM); Adrian Winnubst, GK (HM)
2006: Michael Ragsdale, M (HM); Carl Baker, D (HM); Chad Becker, GK (HM)
2007: Tom Heinemann, F (1st team); Haggai Leboo, F (2nd team); Adam Johnson, M (2nd team); Spencer Martens, D (2nd team)
2008: Tom Heinemann, F (1st team); Spencer Martens, D (1st team); Chad Becker, GK (1st team); Kyle Samuelson, M (2nd team); Charlie Reitz, D (2nd team); Caleb Haydon, D (3rd team)
2009: Heraclio Perez, D (3rd team)
2010: Patrick White, D (2nd team); Nick McDonald, F (2nd team)
2011: Mark Magee, F (1st team); Nick McDonald, F (1st team); Paolo Scoppola, M (1st team); Lucas De Rossi, M (1st team); Kyle Miller, D (1st team); Ryan Bass, GK (1st team); Jon Schreiber, D (2nd team); Ruben Perez, D (3rd team)
2012: Mark Magee, F (1st team); Nick McDonald, F (1st team); Paolo Scoppola, M (1st team); Dan Frohock, D (1st team); Ryan Bass, GK (1st team); Lucas De Rossi, M (2nd team); Jon Schreiber, D (2nd team)
2013: Mark Magee, F (1st team); Paolo Scoppola, M (1st team); Ryan Bass, GK (2nd team); Jon Schreiber, D (2nd team); Ouissie Gueye, D (2nd team); Lucas De Rossi, M (3rd team); George Skevington, D (3rd team)
2014: Nick Caruso, D (2nd team); Adam Michel, M (3rd team)
2015: Nick Caruso, D (1st team); Paul Dean, D (1st team); Kaleb Jackson, F (1st team); Adam Michel, F (2nd team); Mitch Moncada, F (2nd team); Gianlucci Bottoni, M (2nd team); Evan Craig, D (2nd team)
2016: Gianlucci Bottoni, M (1st team); Evan Craig, D (1st team); Kaleb Jackson, F (1st team); Adam Michel, F (2nd team); Matt Collier, D (2nd team); Paul Dean, D (3rd team); Connor Mullen, M (3rd team); Filippo Santandrea, D (3rd team)
2017: Kaleb Jackson, F (1st team); Adam Michel, M (1st team); Connor Mullen, M (1st team); Luca Mastrantonio, D (1st team); Filippo Santandrea, D, (1st team); Logan Feldmann, GK (1st team); Swann Vincent, M (2nd team); Umoh Ufot, F (2nd team); Ben McDonald, D (3rd team); Sal Caruso, D (3rd team)
2018: Filippo Santandrea, D (2nd team); Swann Vincent, D (2nd team); Nandor Benucci, M (3rd team); Pablo Salvador Lopez, M (3rd team)
2019: Federico Verlicchi, D (2nd team)
2022: Gianmarco Donnini, D (1st team); Andrea Dorella, GK (3rd team)
2023: Jacopo Belardo, M (3rd team)
2024: Jacopo Belardo, M (1st team); Blake Barrick, F (1st team)
2025: Immaneul Wayoro, F (1st team); Blake Barrick, F (1st team); Kaden Cripe, M (1st team); Noah Brende, D (1st team); Asier Olano, D (1st team); Franco Briani Brunoro, GK (1st team); Mattia Petricca, D (2nd team)
GLVC Individual Awards
2005 – Haggai Leboo, Freshman of the Year
2008 – Chad Becker, Defensive Player of the Year
2008 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
2011 – Ryan Bass, Defensive Player of the Year
2011 – Lucas De Rossi, Freshman of the Year
2011 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
2012 – Mark Magee, Offensive Player of the Year
2012 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
2015 – Paul Dean, Defensive Player of the Year
2015 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
2016 – Kaleb Jackson, Offensive Player of the Year
2016 – Connor Mullen, Defensive Player of the Year
2016 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
2017 – Kaleb Jackson, Offensive Player of the Year
2017 – Logan Feldmann, Defensive Player of the Year
2017 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
2023 – Sam McIntosh, Freshman of the Year
2024 – Blake Barrick, Freshman of the Year
2025 – Mattia Petricca, Defensive Player of the Year
2025 – Franco Briani Brunoro, Goalkeeper of the Year
2025 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
NAIA National Awards
1976 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
1979 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
1986 – Tony Tocco, Coach of the Year
